External and independent scientific evaluation of the ONB’s indicators
The National Biodiversity Observatory, jointly managed by the French Biodiversity Agency (OFB) and the Data and Statistical Studies Department (SDES) of the Ministry for the Environment, is a multi-partner project that provides the public with accurate and well-documented information on biodiversity in France in the form of indicators covering around ten different themes and environments (forests, seas and coastlines, freshwater, etc.), as well as publications, maps and posters. These indicators describe the state of biodiversity in France, how it is changing, the pressures it faces and the responses from society. All the Observatory’s work, which is discussed collectively, undergoes independent scientific evaluation and is showcased on the naturefrance.fr portal.
More information on the ONB’s indicators
Indicators and maps facilitate dialogue, decision-making and the evaluation of environmental strategies.
In 2012, the ONB decided to bring them together and make them available to potential users by creating an online, open-access database: Biodiversity Indicators Database (i-BD²).
As the indicators provide only fragmentary information, the ONB quickly sought an external perspective on those presented in i-BD². The Foundation for Biodiversity Research (FRB) was therefore asked to examine their scientific relevance, their performance in relation to the characteristics of the datasets, and any biases that might arise in their construction or calculation.
The task entrusted to the experts mobilised by the FRB enables a critical assessment based on scientific criteria, as well as an evaluation of the indicators’ strengths and weaknesses, with a view to proposing either improvements to existing indicators, the creation of new indicators, or their withdrawal from publication. The introduction of a structured evaluation framework enables external, independent scientists to assess the quality of the indicators across various aspects from an objective perspective. The ONB working groups responsible for the indicators then take these evaluations into account to propose avenues for improvement based on the recommendations made.
In any case, the aim is to explain to users the limitations of each indicator and map. Below you will find a list of the indicators and maps assessed, the reports for each financial year, and the publication ‘Scientific evaluation of indicators: the development of an original method’.
The maps assessed are available here. Summary assessments of those listed below are available in the reports for each financial year, which can be downloaded below from the resources section.
- The main map;
- The specific maps presented as insets;
- Climate change
- Habitat destruction
- Invasive alien species
- Land fragmentation
- Pollution
- Over-exploitation of resources
- The overseas maps produced based on expert opinion.
Summary assessments of the indicators listed below are available in the reports for each financial year, which can be downloaded below from the resources section.
2023
- International official development assistance relating to biodiversity
- Financial support from water agencies for wetlands in mainland France
- Incidental catches of common dolphins in fishing gear
- Grape harvest dates in mainland France
- Government expenditure detrimental to biodiversity
- National financial commitment to biodiversity
- Threatened species covered by a national action plan
- Changes in the condition of coral reefs
- Melting of mainland glaciers
- Average annual number of days with frost in mainland France
- Proportion of mainland territory heavily affected by light pollution in the middle of the night
- Proportion of globally threatened species in France
- Proportion of species threatened at European level in mainland France
- Area of mangrove forests subject to conservation measures
- Very large trees and deadwood in forests
2019-2020
Indicators 1 to 7 are new indicators developed by the ONB.
- 1. Organic farming
- 2. Arrival dates of migratory birds
- 3. Trends in wintering waterbird populations
- 4. Initial training courses in the field of biodiversity
- 5. Estimated naturalness of watercourses
- 6. Small watercourses that dry up in summer
- 7. Number of ‘Wetlands’ outreach events
- 8. Trends in natural habitats within areas of outstanding natural beauty
- 9. Trends in dredging in seaports
- 10. Gaps in naturalist knowledge generated and shared in mainland France
- 11. Level of ignorance regarding outstanding habitats
- 12. Number of ecologically functional habitats
- 13. Accuracy of shared data
- 14. Presence of large predators in mainland France
- 15. The main natural habitat in mainland France destroyed by land reclamation
- 16. The main natural habitat in the overseas territories destroyed by land reclamation
- 17. Area covered by marine protected areas
- 18. Very large trees and deadwood in forests
2018
National summary indicators
- 1. Trends in the average number of invasive alien species per metropolitan department
- 2. Consideration of biodiversity by CAC 40 companies
National thematic indicators: ‘Biodiversity & Forest Environments’
- 3. Conservation of the genetic heritage of trees in forests
- 4. Patches of old-growth woodland in public forests
- 5. Timber harvesting in forests relative to tree growth
- 6. Proportion of French people who define forests as a reservoir of biodiversity
- 7. Protected forest areas in mainland France
- 8. Afforestation rate in the overseas territories
- 9. Forest cover in mainland France
National thematic indicators: “Biodiversity & Wetlands”
- 10. Visitor numbers at wetland visitor centres*
- 11. Level of awareness amongst stakeholders regarding wetlands
- 12. Number of Ramsar sites listed in mainland France*
- 13. Number of Ramsar sites listed in the Overseas Territories*
- 14. Ratio of degradation to restoration of predominantly natural wetlands
- 15. Ratio of decline to expansion of predominantly natural wetlands
- 16. Rate of agricultural drainage in mainland France
- 17. Rate of agricultural drainage in the Overseas Territories
Thematic national indicators: “Biodiversity & freshwater environments”
- 18. Trends in pesticide pollution of watercourses in the French overseas departments
- 19. Trends in pesticide pollution of watercourses in mainland France
Thematic national indicators: “Biodiversity & marine and coastal environments”
- 20. Trends in dredging in seaports
- 21. Population pressure on the mainland coastline
National thematic indicators: “Biodiversity & Climate Change”
- 22. Grape harvest dates in mainland France
- 23. Melting of mainland glaciers
- 24. Average annual number of days with frost in mainland France
2015-2016
- 1. International official development assistance relating to biodiversity
- 2. Marine protected areas with a management plan
- 3. Land-use changes in overseas territories
- 4. Land-use changes in mainland France
- 5. Completeness of the network of protected areas for species of conservation concern
- 6. Species displacement linked to climate change
- 7. Structural diversity of mainland forests
- 8. Conservation efforts in areas of outstanding natural beauty
- 9. National financial commitment to biodiversity
- 10. Protected areas listed in the inventory of areas of outstanding natural beauty
- 11. Threatened species covered by a national action plan
- 12. Conservation status of natural habitats
- 13. Status of France’s most characteristic habitats at European level
- 14. Trends in soil bacterial biodiversity
- 15. Trends in the use of plant protection products
- 16. Trends in soil microbial biomass in mainland France
- 17. Trends in participation in educational and civic awareness initiatives on biodiversity
- 18. Trends in river pollution
- 19. Trends in the condition of coral reefs
- 20. Trends in the condition of wetlands
- 21. Trends in citizen involvement in participatory science related to biodiversity
- 22. Trends in bat populations
- 23. Trends in populations of common specialist bird species
- 24. Trends in the surface area of permanent grasslands
- 25. Trends in the number of sea turtle nesting traces in French Overseas Territories
- 26. Trends in the volume of available biodiversity data
- 27. Trends in the volume of wood—particularly beneficial to biodiversity associated with the aging stages of trees—in Metropolitan France
- 28. Fragmentation of watercourses
- 29. Fragmentation of natural habitats
- 30. Hedgerows, woodlands, and heathlands in agricultural landscapes
- 31. Importance placed on biodiversity issues by the French public
- 32. Level of knowledge regarding the distribution of marine species
- 33. Level of dietary diversity among birds
- 34. Extent of the lack of knowledge regarding notable habitats
- 35. Extent of the lack of knowledge regarding the threat status of species
- 36. Level of naturalist surveying in notable sites
- 37. Degree of completeness of the list of known species in French Overseas Territories
- 38. Number of species in French Overseas Territories that are among the most invasive globally
- 39. Number of endemic species in France
- 40. Number of ecologically functional habitats
- 41. Share of French natural areas within the European context
- 42. Proportion of land in French Overseas Departments occupied by ecosystems with minimal human impact
- 43. Proportion of land in Metropolitan France occupied by ecosystems with minimal human impact
- 44. Primary natural habitat in Metropolitan France lost to artificialization
- 45. Primary natural habitat in French Overseas Territories lost to artificialization
- 46. Proportion of mangroves under human pressure
- 47. Proportion of species in Metropolitan France that are extinct or threatened Red Lists
- 48. Proportion of extinct or threatened species in overseas territories, according to Red Lists
- 49. Ecological quality of surface waters
- 50. Responsibility of metropolitan France for species threatened at the European level
- 51. International responsibility of France for the most unique species
- 52. Area of natural habitats in good condition
- 53. Land area covered by protected areas in metropolitan France
- 54. Land area covered by protected areas in overseas territories
- 55. Territory covered by a spatial planning scheme that incorporates biodiversity considerations
2012-2013
- 1. Trends in participation in biodiversity-related awareness and civic education initiatives
- 2. Importance placed on biodiversity issues by the French public
- 3. Trends in citizen involvement in participatory science related to biodiversity
- 4. Proportion of species in metropolitan France that are extinct or threatened, according to Red Lists
- 5. Trends in populations of common specialist bird species
- 6. Threatened species covered by a national action plan
- 7. Marine protected areas with a management plan
- 8. Surface area of terrestrial protected areas in metropolitan France
- 9. Heritage species well-represented within protected areas
- 10. Trends in agro-ecological infrastructure that supports biodiversity
- 11. Trends in the surface area of permanent grassland considered ecologically functional
- 12. Trends in the volume of deadwood in metropolitan France—a key element for biodiversity
- 13. Status of wetlands
- 14. Fragmentation of natural habitats
- 15. Conservation status of natural habitats
- 16. Ecological quality of surface waters
- 17. International public development aid linked to biodiversity
- 18. National expenditure on biodiversity
- 19. Land artificialization in metropolitan France
- 20. Land artificialization in Overseas Territories
- 21. Displacement of species linked to climate change
- 22. Number of species in Overseas Territories that rank among the world’s most invasive
- 23. Trends in watercourse pollution
- 24. Trends in the consumption of plant protection products (pesticides)
- 25. Land area covered by spatial planning schemes that incorporate biodiversity issues
- 26. Level of knowledge regarding the distribution of marine species
- 27. Trends in the volume of data available on biodiversity